In crisis? Free, confidential, 24/7: Call 988, press 1 Text 838255 Chat online
Guide · Claims

Disagree With a VA Decision? Your 3 Options

You have three lanes: Supplemental Claim, Higher-Level Review, or Board Appeal. The right one depends on one question: do you have new evidence? And mind the one-year clock.

First, find your deadline

Look at the date on your decision letter. For most benefits you have 1 year from that date to ask for a Higher-Level Review or a Board Appeal. Some benefit types have shorter limits, so read your letter.

Contested claims (where another person is involved) have a 60-day limit for a Board Appeal.

You can file a Supplemental Claim at any time. But VA recommends filing within 1 year of the decision letter so you keep your original effective date. That date can decide how much back pay you get.

If you miss the 1-year mark for a Higher-Level Review or Board Appeal, you can still file a Supplemental Claim.

Option 1: Supplemental Claim

Use it when: you have new and relevant evidence VA didn't have before, or a law has changed (like the PACT Act).

  • "New" means VA hasn't considered it before.
  • "Relevant" means it helps prove or disprove something in your claim.
  • Form: VA Form 20-0995. Use 21-4142 if you want VA to get records from a private doctor.
  • Online filing works for disability compensation claims only.
  • Speed: VA reported an average of 59.1 days in October 2026 for disability compensation and pension claims. VA's goal is 125 days.
  • Note: A condition that got worse is not a Supplemental Claim. That is a claim for increased compensation.

Option 2: Higher-Level Review (HLR)

Use it when: you have no new evidence, and you think VA made a mistake in law or fact.

  • A more senior reviewer takes a fresh look at the same evidence.
  • You can't submit new evidence.
  • Form: VA Form 20-0996.
  • You can ask for one optional phone call (informal conference) to point out errors. It can make the review slower.
  • VA's goal is 125 days for most claims.
  • You can't ask for an HLR on an issue that already had an HLR or Board Appeal.

Option 3: Board Appeal

Use it when: you want a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans' Appeals to review your case.

Form: VA Form 10182. Pick one of three "dockets":

Docket New evidence? VA's goal (not a promise)
Direct Review No. Judge uses what's in your file. 365 days
Evidence Submission Yes. Send with your request or within 90 days. 550 days
Hearing Optional. At the hearing or within 90 days after. 730 days

If you lose at the Board, you can file a Supplemental Claim with new evidence, or appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims within 120 days.

Which one should I pick?

  • New evidence or new law? Supplemental Claim.
  • No new evidence, and VA clearly got it wrong? Higher-Level Review.
  • Want a judge, or a hearing, and can wait? Board Appeal.
  • Not sure? Talk to an accredited rep before the deadline. It's free through a Veterans Service Organization or your county veterans service officer.

Tips

  1. Write down your deadline the day you get the letter.
  2. Keep your phone number and email current on VA.gov.
  3. You can check your claim status online on VA.gov.
  4. Never pay a company to file for you. See our Scam Shield guide.
  5. Clinical decisions about your treatment follow a different process called a Clinical Appeal.

Who to call

Sources (checked Nov 17, 2026): VA decision reviews; FAQ; Supplemental Claim; Higher-Level Review; Board Appeal.

The MIL Project is not part of VA. The Board numbers above are VA's goals, not promises. Real waits can be longer or shorter. Check VA.gov for current numbers.

Spot something wrong or out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it. The MIL Project is not part of the VA. Confirm details on the official source before you act.